Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I wonder if they have tracking planes or a spotter out on the water. After all this bad press and the violent ocean churn from the last attempt, it would be nice to get a money shot of the vehicle hovering over the water.


It doesn't actually hover over the water. For that, the rocket's thrust would have to exactly balance the weight of the first stage, with the tanks nearly empty, and even a single Merlin engine can't actually throttle down that low. As long as the engine is firing, the rocket is accelerating up, so the actual landing maneuver is something they call a "hoverslam", which is designed to zero out vertical velocity close enough to the ground that after they cut off the engine, the legs can take up the difference.

(Weight conditions at launch are obviously very different. In addition to the weight of the second stage and payload, there's also the weight of the first stage fuel -- and the fuel will be most of the weight of any rocket at launch.)


From what I remember, during the last landing, Elon announced that the Merlin engine can throttle down a lot farther than people though. (IIRC, it can go down to 30%, rather than the 70% figure bandied about in internet rumors.)

This means it's possible for the Falcon to do a constant velocity descent, rather than having to do a hoverslam.



Hmm, but on the grasshopper videos it seems to be hovering in air and descending pretty agiley?


Grasshopper can hover for a while because, at least at that stage in its flight, it is heavier than the returning F9 core. As it burns more and more fuel it becomes lighter and lighter, and I believe that towards the end of Grasshopper flights it is too light to hover.

The landing that Grasshopper has been doing recently, and which the F9 core will do, has been termed a "hover-slam" by SpaceX. Basically it decelerates rapidly, hitting 0m/s right when it also hits the ground. If it did not cut out the engine right at that point, it would begin going back up (until the fuel ran out).


Grasshopper and F9R-1 (their newer test vehicle) are widely believed to fly with extra mass as ballast in order to make them easier to control -- most likely just as extra fuel in the tanks which they don't plan to burn on that flight.


Grasshopper is a testing platform.


You mean like this one (from the last launch)?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CjZ33C9JZTM




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: