Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What "urban concerns" and "rural concerns" are we talking about, specifically?


One in my state is solar panel legislation.

You can't install solar panels in AZ without a permit and building plans and roof plans.

That's all well and good in the city, but here in bumfuck nowhere I built a house with no building plans or roof plans. Why exactly did the majority of city dwellers pass this law without even considering people like me in bumfuck nowhere, who have as much or higher utility for solar panels than even those in urban areas, need to have this regulation?

The answer is they didn't even think about us, they just did it. Now I can't install solar panels without producing a bunch of extra paperwork that city dwellers just assumed everyone already has on hand because in the city you're required to file those when you build the house. Due to that and other rules that are half-cocked consideration for rural counties that don't inspect literally anything else, they basically made it the hardest to put solar in the places where it is most practical and has the most impact.


Literally everything even vaguely construction-ish is rife with crap like this.

It would be one thing if people were actually asking for this regulation because they wanted it. They're mostly not. The trade groups, the professional organizations, the big industry players, they push it and the legislature just writes it knowing full well that the "lives somewhere with good schools" part of their electorate will go to bat for just about any regulation, the landlords can mostly afford it and tenants don't see the true cost. This just leaves the few non-wealthy homeowners (mostly in rural areas where homes are still cheap-ish) and slumlords to complain and so the legislature knows they have nothing to fear at election time.

I don't even live somewhere rural. I live in a proper city. It's just poor enough that stupid rules like that are a massive drag on everyone who wants to do anything. It's hard to amortize needless BS into whatever it is you're doing when the local populace can't afford it.


But who in bumfuck is going to stop you exactly? Are you talking about a grid-tie system, where you feedback to the power company? My experience in rural areas is that after the initial approval for utilities if needed, no one is coming back to inspect anything.


Oh the power company doesn't care. But counties use satellites to find solar panels or other unpermitted installations.

If it's not noticeable via satellite imagery then yeah, probably nothing will happen.


Why is your rural county spending resources to find these unpermitted installations? Sounds like you should vote for better local representatives who don't do stuff you dislike.


To charge fines, I'm sure.

But even if it wasn't your local government, insurance companies do this sort of thing to deny claims even in tangentially related unapproved installations.


> The answer is they didn't even think about us, they just did it.

Asserted without evidence.

Many parts of the USA until sometime in the 1980s had no building codes. Now many of them do (some still go without). Society has made a slow and steady move towards saying, in effect "whatever and wherever you build, we want to be certain that it meets a set of minimum design and construction standards, and we justify this with both public safety (fire, for example) and the interests of anyone who may acquire what you built in the future".

You can say, if you like, that this is bullshit. But don't try to claim that they didn't even think about you.

p.s. I live in rural New Mexico and installed my own solar panels, under license from the state.


The state has no law about me connecting to the electric grid without any building plans, drawings, or inspection. In fact I did so. That's more connected to others than solar panels are.

Just solar panels. They simply forgot.

FYI i built the house after the solar panel law passed. So it's not like it's an old house that needs brought up to modern code or something.


Solar panels are generators that backfeed the line. Power utilities are going to take every opportunity to discourage/prevent/penalize the connection of generators to their lines.

Connecting your house to the grid poses more or less no threat to the grid or the linemen who work on it.


What does that have to roof plans and [structural] building plans? You know, the things I called out.

I've never claimed there is a city/rural contrasting point of relevance on documenting the electrical generation capacity of the solar panels.


You said:

> The state has no law about me connecting to the electric grid without any building plans, drawings, or inspection. In fact I did so. That's more connected to others than solar panels are.

But since your house is (presumably) not a generator, no, that's still less connected to others than even a single solar panel would be.


What on earth do roof and [structural] building plans have to do with eletrical connectivity to the grid? You're losing the plot and trying to lead us down another sideshow, that is the things i called out as the specific things city dwellers forgot I dont have that they require for the solar permit. 'Society' already decided i don't need those for literally anything else residential but solar.

The most likely explanation is they simply forgot rural folks often don't have roof plans, and should have written an exception in such case that the solar permit could be issued without them.


I don't have any specific ones that would be pertinent to this conversation without causing a flame war of some kind, but we can see the general difference based on county level urbanization as it correlates to party voting in the presidential election. Those rural concerns can also vary from one state to another (a core part of why the Senate was created).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: