Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It was a MAGA talking point from the start, meant for MAGA ppl... The chance he got it was 0%, because:

1- The Nobel Peace Prize is chosen by a committee of 5 Norwegians. Having Russia or Israel expressing support doesn't help, it's probably even counterproductive. Random endorsements on Twitter don't matter either..

2- The committee values international cooperation, not trade wars, isolationism, or cozying up to dictators.

3- They prize the defense of democracy, not attacks on it.

4- The cherry on the cake: Machado got the prize while he's been threatening war with Venezuela itself. It almost feels like a big f*ck off



Your last comment isn't very consistent. For one thing the US recognizes Edmundo Gonzalez as the rightful president[1]. Machado helped him during the campaign last year. For another, Machado opposes Maduro's regime and she actually dedicated her prize to Trump.[2]

[1]: https://www.state.gov/secretary-rubios-call-with-the-rightfu...

[2]: https://x.com/MariaCorinaYA/status/1976642376119549990


> she actually dedicated her prize to Trump

Indeed. Juan Guaidó is yesterdays man.

According to the New York Times...

" She has expressed support for the use of force to depose the Maduro regime; one of her advisors told the New York Times that she has coordinated with the Trump administration and that she has a plan for the first hundred hours after his deposition"

Not sure what democratic mandate she has to be in charge post a foreign led military coup - though she is a graduate of the Yale World Fellows programme.

So rather than a big FU it would appear to be more likely to be an attempt to raise her profile to legitimise a US led coup.


Norwegians don't care about legitimizing US coups, and the current US administration is incapable of working with /anyone/ let anyone influencing Norway.


Look at some of the last Nobel prizes in recent times.

2025 Venezuela opposition, 2023 Iranian opposition, 2022 Belarus, Russia opposition ( and +1 for Ukraine ), 2021 Russian opposition ( +philipines ).

If not influenced by the US - it would appear very much aligned.

In the last 5 years, only in 2024 - celebrating a Japanese who campaigns against nuclear weapons - would it appear not to be aligned.


That's certainly ironic and I think the implications are concerning but don't you think Maduro is the one leading a coup? There is solid statistical evidence Gonzalez won the election.


Quite possibly - not fan of Maduro - just responding to the idea that the prize was two fingers up to Trump - when in fact Machado would appear to be very much in the US camp.


Yes, she dedicated her prize to Trump, and that's easy to understand. It's a way to flatter his ego so that:

1- He doesn't turn against her or try to undermine her (he certainly would otherwise)

2- He publicly supports her cause.

3- His attention stays on Venezuela .. I really doubt she wants a full-scale US intervention.


> Having Russia or Israel expressing support doesn't help,

Please. At least get the facts right.

It was not just Russia and Israel. It was also Cambodia, Azerbaijan, Gabon and Rwanda.


Also, the current military dictator of Pakistan, and maybe it was done as a state sponsorship, not just a personal one.


it's not often Gabon shows up to the party. Lol


[flagged]


Just yesterday the orange one called for the arrest of two state governors.

On charges of... uhhh... hm...

Because... uhhmm.. he doesn't like them?


Machado is manufacturing consent for Trump's planned invasion, so point 4 is a bit weaker than you might like. Imagine looKing at Iraq and saying "yeah, that's what I want for my country".




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: