Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You can get screwed over by external (to your org, even more globally) requirements

For example I work for a Research University, mostly our software procurement is - while not always excellent - pretty good stuff. Maybe the supplier isn't as responsive as we'd like, maybe the software is buggier, maybe the documentation is worse, probably not all three.

However, the Government, responding to the usual anti-immigrant sentiment, decided it needs all Universities to check that people who are here on a restricted visa to get a degree attend classes.

The underlying sentiment is clearly racist, but OK in some cases you could imagine that's a real issue, a cheap course with foreign students who are registered but actually never attending because they're out delivering pizza or whatever. For a prestige research University though it doesn't make much sense - maybe you graduated top of your class in Taiwan, your parents pay an eyewatering sum so you can study here for an EE Masters to get that job back home with a team designing CPUs - then instead you skip classes to work as a taxi driver? No, absurd. But the government legally requires we solve this imaginary problem, and the only bidding supplier is garbage. So they're basically requiring us to procure garbage.

Because the supplier knows we're obligated, why should they support anything? Why care if it works, or is documented properly, or integrates with all the things they've told the government it can do? They know they're getting free money because of anti-immigrant sentiment, and they can take advantage of that until the winds change.

Their attendance tracking stuff could be useful. You can legitimately imagine having an early warning, OK, Sarah took a week for her mum's funeral, that's sad, but then she didn't attend any lectures at all for the next three weeks, we should have somebody go check Sarah is OK, or, well, she's clearly not OK, have them figure out what Sarah should do next. Take a year pause? Counselling on our dime? Right now, we aren't required to track Sarah unless she's on a restricted visa and the software is awful (for her, for us, for her teaching staff, everything) so we don't track her. So chances are nobody notices, especially if her class is big, and then in another month's time we find out Sarah was struggling after losing a parent, and we find that out because Police have to break her door open as she's been dead for long enough that neighbours noticed the smell.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: