Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It seems great until those imaginary numbers become worthless overnight.

Then you might have a bit of an "oh shit" moment as you realize that the industrial ecosystem required to substitute those imports would take a decade and a half to build even if your money were worth something, which it now isnt.

Lots of countries collapse due to overreliance on foreign imports. Argentina never recovered from its peak in the 1920s - it just kept bouncing from crisis to crisis. This is looking like an increasingly plausible outcome for the US.



Why would they become worthless? The entire world is forever beholden to Microsoft Windows, Office, AWS, X, iOS, Google Play, whether people like it or not. People have made free or cheaper or local or better alternatives and they have never succeeded at dethroning these


I don’t think they’re as beholden as you think. If those companies went down, a balkanization of tech would probably emerge, with regional preferences. Probably would spur innovation and consumers would quickly adapt.


For sure! All you gotta do is the thing every developing economy on the planet has been attempting and failing to do which is escape the middle income trap.

The US is unique in its vision to step backwards into the middle income trap amongst the rest of 'em.


> Microsoft Windows, Office, AWS, X, iOS, Google Play

One of these things is not like the others.


Laughably so...

1. The operating system running a lot of corporate software

2. Productivity suite that is still the standard for creating documents

3. Cloud infrastructure that scales to any demand

4. Porn and racism

5/6. The worlds only mobile operating systems and dominant app stores


> forever beholden to Microsoft Windows, Office, AWS, X, iOS, Google Play,

There is one country that is very much not as beholden as everyone else. Even if everyone calls it a "PPT", it's quite often going to come from WPS.

Though the state of Linux support for things like WeChat/Com is... Not great. But there been a uptick in inquiries about Linux support for a system in the last 2 months so something's lit a fire under some posteriors recently.


I was talking about the US as a reserve currency. That's what is driving the deficit and how the US has been exchanging bits on a screen for free stuff for the last ~50 years or so.

It would collapse in value overnight if there were a run on the dollar (treasury holdings were sold off). Then hyperinflation would set in and import dependence would become existential.


Microsoft, AWS, Google (et al) pays bribes in dollars.


So then wouldn't the smart play to be to trade those imaginary numbers for real industrial equipment today while we build out factories? The Trumpist plan seems to be just smash the economy and then hope that will somehow force us to build back.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: