Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

$1k just ain't what it used to be. My wife and I just spent $5k on a sectional from West Elm a year ago and the fabric is already starting to pill.


This is why I trust IKEA’s price to quality ratio. I know I won’t be getting the highest quality, but I will likely be getting the highest quality to price ratio.

Got this one in 2016 for $1,100, and it’s survived 2 kids with minimal pilling. It won’t impress anyone, but I have no problem using it.

https://www.ikeaddict.com/ikeapedia/en/Product/60276883/us-e...

I have no way of discerning furniture/fabric quality, and no one offers long warranties, so I don’t see a reason to spend more than IKEA prices.


Yeah, the correct choices for furniture these days are basically: used (cheap if you’re not buying something trendy like mid century modern), IKEA, or super-expensive really-good stuff. Anything new that’s cheaper than that last category’s usually just gonna be as bad or worse than IKEA, plus 1.2x-5x the price. And likely uglier.


Oof! For $5k you could get something from Herman Miller, Hay, or Design Within Reach[1].

[1] https://www.dwr.com/living-sofas-sectionals/quilton-chaise-s...


I think even showy luxury brands like RH do better than West Elm. CB2 as well, which is a slight step up from Crate and Barrel.

West Elm and the whole Pottery Barn set of brands are just worse versions of Crate and Barrel, with terrible customer service to go with it. They had some of the most mean and rude customer service agents I’ve ever talked to. They acted like the store was an entirely different company, then the store acted like I needed to call the national call line. Plus, they outsource deliveries in a very annoying blame-shifting way.

At least at RH you get a single human point of contact who can handle everything like a concierge experience.


Yeah, their price point is totally baffling given the quality, service, and delivery issues.


Ironic, that same item you mention has 2 reviews (out of 3) complaining about worn out fabric within months. And almost $5k.


Not really ironic. It's available in 10 different fabric options. If you're surprised that a wool/alpaca blend fabric isn't heard wearing, or that boucle snags easily then you didn't think through the purchase. I have a similar sofa with the Beck fabric and it's great for the way I use it. The flambier boucle fabric looks great, but as a cat owner, I'd never purchase it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: