The posts about Resig that I can see by Peter Michaux and David Mark seem to be mostly empty of content and filled with petty namecalling. Do you have any specific review/critique that you think is helpful?
For what it’s worth, Secrets of the JS Ninjas is one of the most illuminating JavaScript resources I’ve seen anywhere – I don’t know anyone who wasn’t able to learn something from reading it, including skilled, seasoned JS developers, and several of its insights can’t be found anywhere else so far as I know – and it’s at this point still a half-written draft.
For what it’s worth, Secrets of the JS Ninjas is one of the most illuminating JavaScript resources I’ve seen anywhere – I don’t know anyone who wasn’t able to learn something from reading it, including skilled, seasoned JS developers, and several of its insights can’t be found anywhere else so far as I know – and it’s at this point still a half-written draft.