Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The problem isn't monopolized pharmaceuticals, other countries deal with that as well nor is it too much regulation, it's too little.

Other countries simply accept that there is a monopoly and that therefore the prices will be sky high, if they allow the companies to just set the prices to whatever they want, so these governments set prices and negotiate or empower consumers.

The situation in the US would be very different, if you had nationwide insurance agencies and medicare negotiating drug prices and being able to say no to drugs that provide little to no benefit.



> nor is it too much regulation, it's too little

I think the framing of regulation as a spectrum of less to more is unhelpful. We don't need more regulation, we need better regulation. Some better is more; sometimes it's less.


> The problem isn't monopolized pharmaceuticals

True. The problem is IP law.

> nor is it too much regulation, it's too little

IP law is a form of regulation

> Other countries simply accept that there is a monopoly

There wouldn't be, if not for IP law

> that therefore the prices will be sky high, if they allow the companies to just set the prices to whatever they want

They can only set the prices so high because they have a government-enforced monopoly on those products due to IP law

The US needs to focus on further opening markets. Make the markets more easily accessible to competition. That means reducing the regulatory restrictions to something reasonable and, like you suggest, opening all markets for competition from everywhere.

I would love to be able to just buy catastrophic healthcare insurance for unforeseen or accidental injuries or illnesses, and just paying for healthcare checkups out-of-pocket. But is that option open to me? Not really.

I'm open to considering the idea of implementing a nationwide single payer system but I'd prefer it to be handled on a per-state basis first to test how it would work, and what kinds of unforeseen consequences it would have.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: